Harley-Davidson Nightster vs Honda Rebel 500
Specs side by side, plus our verdict on which one is the smarter buy for the way you ride.
The Harley-Davidson Nightster and Honda Rebel 500 are among the most cross-shopped cruiser bikes of 2026. The Honda Rebel 500 undercuts the Harley-Davidson Nightster by about $5,500, so value is squarely on the table. On paper the Harley-Davidson Nightster leads on power with 91 hp. Below we put them head to head on price, performance, weight and seat height, then give our verdict on which one is the smarter buy for the way you ride.
Harley-Davidson
Harley-Davidson Nightster
Our pickHonda
Honda Rebel 500The verdict
The Honda Rebel 500 edges it overall at 7.9/10, but the Harley-Davidson Nightster wins on most exciting, so let how you ride decide.
Honda Rebel 500
A2-legal, 46 hp, forgiving to learn on.
Harley-Davidson Nightster
91 hp and 0.41 hp/kg, the strongest here.
Honda Rebel 500
Our 7.9/10 at $6,499, the most bike per dollar.
Honda Rebel 500
188 kg with an 690 mm seat, the easiest to throw around.
Honda Rebel 500
Our top score in this matchup at 7.9/10.
Cyan marks the best figure in each row. Specs are the most-cited for the current model; verify before relying on them.
Still torn between them?
Answer a few questions and we'll rank every bike by how well it fits you.
Harley-Davidson Nightster vs Honda Rebel 500: your questions answered
Which is faster, the Harley-Davidson Nightster or the Honda Rebel 500?
The Harley-Davidson Nightster makes the most power at 91 hp and 95 Nm, giving it the edge on outright performance.
Which is cheaper, the Harley-Davidson Nightster or the Honda Rebel 500?
The Honda Rebel 500 is the most affordable here with an MSRP around $6,499.
Which is lighter, the Harley-Davidson Nightster or the Honda Rebel 500?
The Honda Rebel 500 is the lightest at 188 kg, which makes it the easiest to manage at low speed and in the bends.
Which is better for a beginner, the Harley-Davidson Nightster or the Honda Rebel 500?
For a new rider we'd point to the Honda Rebel 500: A2-legal, 46 hp and 188 kg make it the most approachable of the group.
